Quality of Care Whistleblowers at Nursing Homes

Whistleblowers can report Skilled Nursing Facilities providing substandard care to Medicare and Medicaid patients.  The nursing home violates the False Claims Act if the services are so deficient that they are effectively worthless.  A nurse, patient or the patient’s family can report the facility to the Department of Justice and eligible individuals can potentially earn a reward if the U.S. is able to recover the funds it spent on healthcare at the nursing home.

Skilled nursing providers are paid a per diem rate by Medicare and Medicaid.  If they are not providing the services required by the government, their submission for payment may constitute a false claim.  The Department of Justice has successfully litigated several cases to settlements using this theory.

Potential Violations by Nursing Homes

Worthless Services

The failure to provide adequate care to residents is actionable if it is so materially deficient as to cross the line according to federal and state.  Some courts may also find liability if the service is not completely worthless but is sufficiently below the standard for expected care to be considered a violation of the false claims act.  Some examples of deficient care would include insufficient staff, inadequate catheter care, insufficient protocols to prevent  falls or pressure ulcers, and inadequate care of infections and bed sores.

Unnecessary Rehabilitation

The amount of therapy provided to patients must be determined by patient need rather than the financial motives of the therapy company.  Companies may not subject patients to therapy goals or durations that are unrealistic given their condition.  They may not ramp up the amount of therapy during assessment periods without clinical justification in order to increase the amount they can bill.

Other

Nursing homes may also violate the law for improper kickbacks and referrals under the Anti-Kickback Statute and the Stark Law.  These cases would involve payments for the referral of patients to the nursing home or nursing home patients to outside vendors.  The law may also be violated when the owner owns both the skilled nursing facility and the other entity receiving or providing the referral.

The Role of Whistleblowers

The government strengthened the public-private partnership between whistleblowers and the U.S. Government in 1986 when it amended the False Claims Act. It compensates whistleblowers in order to incentivize them to provide information about fraud against the federal government. If individuals did not come forward with nonpublic information, the U.S. would have a difficult time policing violations of its laws, regulations and contracts.

There are many individuals that could report a skilled nursing facility for insufficient care.  Over the years, there have been many nurse whistleblowers who have grown tired of the conditions there patients are subjected to by the home.  Administrators have discovered that regulations are not being followed and blown the whistle.  Even patient’s families have reported problems in the care of their loved ones.  If you have evidence of misconduct, the quality of your evidence is more important than your position.

The Reasons to Report

Many individuals simply grow tired of watching their patients suffer and decide to put a stop to it.  Others discover that they may receive a large payment for doing the right thing.  Relators, as the individuals are known under the law, are entitled to an award of between 15 and 30 percent of the U.S. Government’s recovery under the law.  There are a number of terms and conditions to determine eligibility for this payment, however.

The False Claims Act

The False Claims Act imposes substantial penalties on doctors, hospitals and other health care companies engaged in fraud while rewarding whistleblowers for providing evidence of the misconduct to the Justice Department through a qui tam lawsuit.

Our Federal False Claims Act lawyers have guided whistleblower cases to several significant settlements on behalf of relators. Our largest unsealed cases are currently focused on kickbacks in violation of the Anti-Kickback Statute, but we have a broad base of experience across other types of Medicaid and Medicare fraud. In the pursuit of suspected frauds, we have brought cases to the attention of the government in many states, including New York, Florida, California and here in Philadelphia. In 2016, for example, we helped the federal and state governments recover $54 million from a Valeant subsidiary for kickbacks paid through speaker programs.

The law rewards whistleblowers for information with between 15 and 30 percent of the proceeds from the litigation, subject to numerous terms and conditions specified in the law. During President Obama's Administration, the U.S. paid out more than $4 billion to whistleblowers. For those not familiar with whistleblower cases, we have written a quick guide to the process.

Our False Claims Act attorneys undertake a thorough review of whistleblower evidence up front during the case evaluation process. We confirm that there is sufficient evidence of both inappropriate government billings as well as evidence of intentional or reckless conduct by the individuals in charge. We understand that no one person needs to have every piece of the puzzle and we have evaluated thousands of potential cases while honing our judgment. We also answer any questions that a whistleblower has in order to ensure that you can make an informed judgment about whether to proceed with a qui tam lawsuit.

To begin the process and get your questions answered, use our contact form or call 1-800-590-4116 for a free, confidential and no-obligation initial legal consultation from our whistleblower attorneys.

Call 1-800-590-4116 to Speak to a McEldrew Young AttorneyEmail Us